Dr. Chaoulli's private clinic waiting room death
Waiting-room death triggers review of Quebec private clinic rules
Canadian Medicine
April 22, 2009
Quebec coroner Catherine Rudel-Tessier’s report released today on the death of Jean-Jacques Sauvageau, who died January 11, 2008, in the waiting room of a private Montreal urgent-care clinic, demands that the Collège des médecins du Québec refine its regulations on such clinics to better protect patients.
Ms Rudel-Tessier said the 2007 Collège guidelines on private clinic administration should be “more precise” on certain points and must help administrators “offer a safe environment to their patients and permit them to adequately deal with emergencies.”
The Collège’s president and CEO, Dr Yves Lamontagne, said the guidelines would be either revised or replaced, depending on the results of the Collège’s investigation of the incident. He said he expects two new measures will be incorporated into the guidelines. “One, every physician or nurse working in that type of clinic should follow a course on cardiopulmonary resuscitation. And two, all clinics should have equipment — a defibrillator.”
Ms Rudel-Tessier also recommended that the Collège investigate the doctor or doctors who attended to Mr Sauvageau.
Dr Jacques Chaoulli — the same crusading Jacques Chaoulli whose high-profile 2005 Supreme Court case against the government of Quebec forced the province to overturn some of its restrictions on private health insurance — examined Mr Sauvageau minutes after he stopped breathing and decided not to attempt resuscitation, instead leaving Mr Sauvageau’s body in his waiting room seat until an ambulance arrived. An autopsy later revealed that Mr Sauvageau died of massive bilateral pulmonary embolisms and would not have been saved by resuscitation but Ms Rudel-Tessier concluded that Dr Chaoulli could not have known that at the time and should have tried to save Mr Sauvageau.
http://canadianmedicine.blogspot.com/2009/04/waiting-room-death-triggers-review-of.html
Rapport d’enquête sur LE DÉCÈS DE M. JEAN-JACQUES SAUVAGEAU
http://qgov.newswire.ca/gouvqc/communiques/GPQF/Avril2009/22/c4034.html?slang=en
Comment:
By Don McCanne, MD
In the Canadian Supreme Court case of Chaoulli v. Quebec, Justice Deschamps wrote, “The evidence in this case shows that delays in the public health care system are widespread, and that, in some serious cases, patients die as a result of waiting lists for public health care.”
This decision has resulted in intense efforts to privatize both the Canadian health insurance system and the Canadian health care delivery system. The outspoken proponents of privatization would have you believe that only the private sector is capable of saving lives that would be lost by neglect in the public sector.
Dr. Chaoulli’s patient did not die while on a waiting list for an elective orthopedic procedure. He collapsed and died in Dr. Chaoulli’s private waiting room. Dr. Chaoulli withheld cardiopulmonary resuscitation - a standard of care that surely would have been provided in any public health care facility - with questions over whether or not he had adequately trained staff and appropriate equipment to initiate such care. Dr. Chaoulli then asked his nurse to call 911 (to have the body removed), and he returned to his work. Only after the ambulance team arrived was cardiopulmonary resuscitation instituted.
The lesson of the tragic death of Jean-Jacques Sauvageau is simply that Crusader Dr. Jacques Chaoulli and the other privatizers have no credibility when they claim that the private system has a special capability of saving lives that the public system lacks.